2008 - Which Of The -BMW Audi Mercedes - Is A Design Leader For The Recently Years

[semisaleh]

HEY ALL I THINK ITS TIME TO DISCUSS ...WHICH OF THE THREE LEXURY SEGMENTS IS A DESIGN LEADER ...AND WHO DO U THINK IS A SUCCESS CLASSIC DESIGN FOR THE NEXT 10 YEARS...

[Just_me]

Overall I prefer BMW design but MB has some models I like - C-class and SL and Audi got A5 and A8.

[Tarek]

Well i'm a Mb fan and of course one of the reason is i love how Benzes look,only one or two models that i don't like.BMW on the other i only like 3er coupe,X6 and 1er.Audi has S5,S8 and R8 goin for me

[semisaleh]

- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER
- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER
- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER
[url=http://g.imageshack.us/g.php?h=525&i=84050384ol6.jpg][IMG


[url=http://imageshack.us][/


- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER
- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER
- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

[coolraoul]

Well, I am a MB fan.

However, for me and from a theoretical PoV, BMW is undoubtedly the design leader of the three (even if I hate their look, it stands out and was an obvious inspiration especially for MB). Audi had a very pure design, but their strategy of copy-pasting the design with only one or two differences like the tailamps is showing a lack of new ideas. Usually one new idea every three or four car (new spaceframe grille. Then new interior. Then new rear design).

So I would say, the design leader is BMW, the usually more attractive car is MB, the most Germanic design is Audi.

All that seen with an "unbiased" eye, because personally I would rank MB first, Audi second, BMW third in terms of pleasantness of design.


Concerning the true classic, I think the most likely to get a "design icone" status in the history is the CLS. This will mark the history of MB, for me.
Another strong candidate is the e65 for its new ideas and unique design theme.
Concerning Audi I would say the first TT.

[Merc1]

Originally Posted by coolraoul

So I would say, the design leader is BMW, the usually more attractive car is MB, the most Germanic design is Audi.

All that seen with an "unbiased" eye, because personally I would rank MB first, Audi second, BMW third in terms of pleasantness of design.

Bingo! I agree. Though I'd still say Audi has the best looking lineup in the industry.

M

[SDNR]

If we are talking about styling then the true design leader in the group has been BMW. BMW's styling is expressive of the chaos, dynamism, speed, and disharmony of contemporary global culture; it is exciting, energetic, aggressive, and fascinating.

Audi is very in tune with what is happening at the elite levels of industrial design -- it is less about dynamic styling and more about an idealized expression of order and harmony. I find Audi design to be the most academic of the three ...perhaps the most intelligent.

Mercedes has followed the changing tastes in the market the closest ....they have adapted particularly to emerging trends coming out of the US. Mercedes is the one that seeks to make connections with its historical past through archetypal design elements -- BMW has the kidney grille and Hoffmeister kink ...but these are not used to evoke history like Mercedes does. Mercedes makes subtle references to its iconic models from the past through the use of stylized retro elements.

[Tarek]

Originally Posted by SDNR

Mercedes has followed the changing tastes in the market the closest ....they have adapted particularly to emerging trends coming out of the US. Mercedes is the one that seeks to make connections with its historical past through archetypal design elements -- BMW has the kidney grille and Hoffmeister kink ...but these are not used to evoke history like Mercedes does. Mercedes makes subtle references to its iconic models from the past through the use of stylized retro elements.

I have to say that u surprised me with this paragraph Rob,i was expecting this thread to be ur long awaited chance to hammer MB's design

[semisaleh]

BUT REALLY I DONT UNDERSTAND WHY.....EVERYBODY LOVE MERCEDES ...AND FEEL IT IN HEART....WITH THIER DESIGN///AND WHY MB MODELS COME CLASSICS AFTER 10 YEARS WHILE BMW BECOME RUBBISH

[Just_me]

Originally Posted by semisaleh

AFTER 10 YEARS WHILE BMW BECOME RUBBISH

WHAT???? elaborate please